Skip to content

Our independence

Independent,by design.

A badge is only worth something if nobody can buy it, bend it, or lean on the people who give it. Here's how we make sure of that.

How we're funded

Money is where independence usually breaks. So we're specific about ours.

Paid for by

  • Makers catalog memberships
  • Sponsors who serve makers, never shops we rate
  • Tickets to the yearly announcement

Never paid for by

  • Shops we rate, in any way
  • Badges, placement or faster reviews
  • Maker stories, which the panel picks

How the panel works

Working makers

Every panel member sells their own work. No shop owners, buyers or sponsors.

Kept anonymous

Names stay private so no one can be pressured, flattered or targeted.

Rotated often

Members serve up to two years, so no group decides for long.

Decide together

Badges need agreement from the panel, never one person's call.

Conflicts of interest

The people who started Makers Badge are makers too, and they sell their own work in shops. They follow exactly the same rules as the panel.

Corrections and appeals

If we get something wrong, tell us. Every message gets a reply within two weeks, and corrections are published on the shop's entry with the date.

See something we got wrong?