Skip to content

How we rate

Hard to earn.Impossibleto buy.

A badge only means something if it's hard to earn and impossible to buy. Here's exactly how it works, so any maker or shop can hold us to it.

The bar

First, a shop must meet all five requirements. Then its scores must clear the bar. Miss one, and there is no badge this year.

Open at least a year

Long enough for makers to know how a shop really works.

A written agreement

Every maker gets clear terms in writing, before stock goes on the shelf.

Verified ratings

From at least three different makers, each with private proof they sold there.

Unpaid makers

No confirmed reports of a maker going unpaid in the last year.

A panel visit

A panel member visits unannounced, like any other customer.

4.2

Average score or higher

Across all 15 questions, out of 5.

3.5

Lowest area score

No area can fall below this. Great display does not make up for late pay.

The 15 questions

Makers who sell in a shop answer all 15, from 1 (poor) to 5 (great), based on the last 12 months.

Paid fairly

  • Do they pay on time, every time?
  • Are sales statements clear and accurate?
  • Is the commission fair for what they offer?

Clear terms

  • Is the agreement in writing?
  • Are there no surprise fees or deductions?
  • Do they stick to what they agreed?

Cares for the work

  • Is the work displayed well?
  • Is it handled with care, and damage covered?
  • Is unsold stock returned in good shape?

Good to deal with

  • Do they reply quickly?
  • Are they honest about what is selling?
  • Are they open to feedback?

Champions makers

  • Do they credit makers by name?
  • Do they promote makers' work?
  • Are they welcoming to new makers?

The year, in order

The Guide runs on a yearly cycle, like any good award. Every badge is earned fresh, and the first edition is announced in October 2027.

1November to June

Ratings are open

Any maker who sells in a shop can rate it, with private proof.

2July

Ratings close and are checked

The panel verifies proof and removes anything that does not hold up.

3August

The panel visits and decides

Panel members visit shortlisted shops unannounced, then decide together. No one votes on a shop they sell in.

4September

Shops hear first, in private

Each shop is told before anyone else, and asked to confirm its details.

5October

The new Guide is published

Badges for the year go live at the announcement evening, just before holiday shopping, with decals sent to every shop.

Our promises

These don't change, no matter how big the Guide gets.

Never for sale

No shop can pay for a badge, a better spot, or a faster review.

No ads from shops

The Guide is never paid for by the shops it rates.

The panel stays anonymous

So no one can be pressured. Panel members are working makers.

Conflicts are skipped

Panel members never vote on a shop they sell in.

Proof is deleted

Once a rating is checked, the proof is gone. Only the scores stay.

Earned again every year

A badge from last year does not carry over. Every shop starts fresh.

Questions about a rating?

Every message gets a reply within two weeks.